Should You List Your Home Over the Holidays? Here Is What the Data Says

Every year around this time, I hear the same thing from homeowners: "We will list in the spring." It is the conventional wisdom. Spring is when the market is busiest, so that must be when you get the best price.

Sometimes that is true. But the busiest market is also the most crowded one. Here is what the numbers say, and how I would decide.

Fewer listings means less competition

According to the National Association of REALTORS®, December is usually the month with the fewest homes for sale all year. Many sellers hold off until spring, so the homes that are listed have less competition for buyers' attention.

NAR's economists describe December through February as having "the lowest competition levels of the year." They also found that prices in December are typically about 0.5% higher than in November, because fewer homes are on the market.

The buyers who are out are serious

Nobody tours homes the week before Christmas for fun. Holiday buyers usually have a reason to move: a job relocation, a lease ending, a growing family, or a tax deadline.

NAR also reports that first-time buyers make up about 31.8% of home sales on average, and their share usually rises slightly in December.

San Diego is not Chicago

In much of the country, winter shuts the market down. NAR found that in the Midwest, twice as many homes sell in June as in January. But it also found that the West is the region least affected by seasonality.

In San Diego, a December weekend can be 70 degrees and sunny. Your yard looks the same as it does in April. Out-of-state buyers relocating for work are not scared off by snow on the ground.

The trade-offs

Listing over the holidays is not right for everyone. Be realistic about the downsides:

  1. Homes take longer to sell. NAR found the median time on market from December through February is about 49 days, compared to about 33 days in the spring.

  2. Fewer buyers overall. Winter has fewer sellers, but it also has fewer buyers. The spring market brings more of both.

  3. Prices are higher in the summer. NAR reported that homes sell for about 16% more in June than in the winter months. Part of that is simply that more expensive homes tend to sell in summer, but it is worth knowing.

  4. Your schedule. Showings during the holidays take some flexibility, and you may need to keep the house show-ready with family in town.

When I would list now

  • You need to move in the next few months, and waiting for spring means carrying two homes or extending a lease.

  • Your home is move-in ready. Winter buyers have fewer choices, and a well-prepared home stands out.

  • You want to buy in the spring yourself. Selling in winter lets you buy with cash in hand instead of a contingent offer.

  • Your home is in a neighborhood where few homes come up for sale. Less competition helps most when supply is already tight.

When I would wait

  • Your home needs work, and spring gives you time to do it right.

  • You have no deadline and want the largest possible pool of buyers.

Bottom line

Spring is not automatically the best time to sell. It is the most popular time, which is not the same thing. If you are ready, a holiday listing in San Diego can mean less competition and more serious buyers. If you are not ready, use the next few months to prepare, and list in early spring before the crowd shows up.

Thinking about selling and not sure about the timing? Send me a note.

Sources:

Bassem Elsayeh
REALTOR® | REeBroker Group | CA DRE #01901933

Next
Next

Prop 19 in Plain English: How to Keep Your Low Property Tax When You Move or Inherit